Sunday, May 9, 2010
Journal # 3- My Sister's Keeper
As the novel, My Sister's Keeper, progresses, more conflicts and decisions arise. The previous chapter I read was focussed more on Jesse and his decisions. Jesse is the eldest son and he tries to stay distant from his family. He has chosen to live away from his family, he stays in a room above the garage, a place he calls his own away from his family. He has made bad decisions such as drinking and smoking. "I am the kind who played with matches." (pg. 111) This shows that he doesn't get alot of attention from his parents since they took no action to stop him from doing these things. They also took no objection of him living away from the rest of the family. After his sister was diagnosed with APL, Sara and Brian have not been giving much attention to Jesse which makes him feel neglected and unimportant, and perhaps that is the reason why he acts the way he does. Jesse is greatly effected by his family's situation, just as much as Anna is affected. Although he isn't affected physically, he is emotionally. His decisions are clarified by the fact that he is neglected, which shows that he is greatly effected by the people around him. Maybe if he was given the attention he needed he wouldn't involve himself in crime and drugs."[Jesse] I'm sure I'm worth alot more dead than alive..." (pg. 112) There is always a story or a reason behind each and every decision. A decision is made from influence, reason, and curiosity. I've noticed in this novel that there is a great chain of influence that leads to most of the decisions made by all the characters. The chain of choices started with Kate and her diagnosis. This led to all the attention being focussed on her and away from Jesse, and this led to Jesse's decisions. The attention his parents gave Kate led to the decision of concieving Anna, and this led to many problems along the way such as Anna's decision to sue her parents. I haven't finished the book, but i predict the chain will continue untill the end.
Wednesday, April 28, 2010
Journal # 2- My Sister's Keeper
My Sister's Keeper is a novel that I can't seem to put down. Jodi Picoult has me enticed and captivated. Countless emotions run through me, from laughter to tears, and this is exactly what the author has succeeded in doing. As the story of Kate and Fitzgerald family progresses, more decisions are being made and characters are becoming more affected by them, both physically and emotionally. The decision to concieve Anna in order to save Kate's life has backfired and consequences start to arise. "The fact that the only reason I was born was as a harvest crop for Kate" (pg. 21) Anna no longer agrees to donate parts of herself (stem cells and blood) to her sister, Kate. She has decided to sue her parents for the rights to her own body and has even hired an attorney to ensure this happens. "It's not God. Just my parents, I say. I want to sue them for the rights to my own body." (pg. 21) Anna's decision to take it to court and the decision of her attorney, Campbell, to support her are most important decisions and issue in the novel. Campbell knew that she's just a child and might not know what she's doing and he knows that it could result in Kate's death. Perhaps he agreed because it was his job, not because he truly suported Anna. This shows that sometimes people don't entirely control the decisions they make. They are sometimes made for them or influenced by other people. Anna's decision has impacted everyone around her, even herself. "For God's sake, Anna, mother says. Do you even realize what the consequences would be?"(pg. 63) Her mother, Sara, is appalled and distraught about the idea, Brian, her father, is not taking sides, " And my father: Who said there were sides?"(pg. 68) Jesse is not getting any attention and Kate just wants let Anna know that she loves her. Anna's parents think shes doing this to get the attention she never had. "She's doing it for the attention."(pg. 67) This decision was the reason for alot of the issues that started to occur. Kate can no longer get stem cell donations she needs, stress has increased in their household, and the whole issue has been take to court. From just one decision derives anger, sadness and disapointment, all of them consequences.
Everyone has faced consequences in their lifetime, both good and bad. I try to avoid bad consequences by making the right decisions in the first place. Other times I can have the same experience as Campbell, it's either I don't have an option or the decision is influenced by another factor. Whenever I have homework, I always find myself contemplating whether to do it or not when I know that I should. It's the factors around me that influence me to procrastinate and leave my home work aside. Such as; t.v, computer, friends and fatigue. In the novel, there are factors affecting Anna's decision such as pain, and attention. Making a decision is not an easy thing and it can take time to either develop the state of mind or courage to go on with it.
Everyone has faced consequences in their lifetime, both good and bad. I try to avoid bad consequences by making the right decisions in the first place. Other times I can have the same experience as Campbell, it's either I don't have an option or the decision is influenced by another factor. Whenever I have homework, I always find myself contemplating whether to do it or not when I know that I should. It's the factors around me that influence me to procrastinate and leave my home work aside. Such as; t.v, computer, friends and fatigue. In the novel, there are factors affecting Anna's decision such as pain, and attention. Making a decision is not an easy thing and it can take time to either develop the state of mind or courage to go on with it.
Sunday, April 25, 2010
Journal # 1 - My Sister's Keeper
The novel I am currently reading is called My Sister's Keeper by Jodi Picoult. It's a touching story about a young girl who has leukemia. It tells the story of the family's hardship and the sacrifices they make. Part of the hardship the family faces is the difficulty of making decisions and the consequences they face as the story progresses. Kate was diagnosed with a rare case of APL leukemia when she was very young. Her mother, Sara, swore that she wouldn't let Kate die, with an expected life span of about 3 years. She was determined to save her daughter at any cost, that's what mothers do. Perhaps some people don't even have a choice, when it comes to life and death the choice to save a life or to live would outweigh the other. Sara couldn't do nothing and not act on a decision that would save Kate's life. She didn't care about anything else and she didn't think of the consequences. It was as if she had no choice, that's why she made a decision that would potentially save Kate's life regardless of the consequences in the future. A decision based on life or death is a strong factor that can blind a person from rationality and logic, thus restricting the person from thinking about consequences. Thinking about the consequences of a decision is always the first step in making one, and by making a choice without thinking, that's when unwanted outcomes and circumstances take their place. Sara was at a crossroads and the thought of losing her daughter only frightened her. She came to a decision and that was to conceive a genetically altered child , she would be the perfect match for Kate to recieve stem cells from. This was the only option Sara had, and she took it. She did not think about the complications of having a third child and the pain and hardship she would have to face when always donating parts of herself to Kate. Anna is this third child, and ever since she was born, every time Kate was at the hospital, so was she. Now Anna is living a life of uncertainty
with the thought of her only being born to save her sister . Sara's decision has effected Kate in a positive way and Anna in a negative way. Decisions always have conseqeunces, whether they're good or bad.
with the thought of her only being born to save her sister . Sara's decision has effected Kate in a positive way and Anna in a negative way. Decisions always have conseqeunces, whether they're good or bad.
Friday, January 29, 2010
Media Critique
After reading the article on BBC and The Rawandan Girl Who Refused to Die, it really gave me a clearer picture of how evil looks like. The short story is a about a brave and strong girl who survived a great tragedy. She was at church with her family when the Hutus attacked. She watched her family die before her eyes and she couldn't do anything about it. The killers were ruthless and showed no mercy. The only way to survive was to hide among the dead bodies of her loved ones. She lost her fingers and suffered major head wounds, but she kept her faith strong and made it through. Her name is Valentina, and she endured what no child should ever go through, ever.
The article was about a man who had taken part in the killings of the church where Valentina was. He explains how he killed his friends, neighbours and spared no lives. He said that the killers were fighting over the victims. This shows great darkness in the hearts of these men. They were bloodthirsty for lives of the tutsi's, even for the children. Evil has no limits, there are no exceptions. They couldve at least spared the lives of children but didn't
The author conveys and integrate imagery, setting and work on mood through his descriptions and the details associated with it. "...skeletal apparition lying on a camp bed in a country where corpses littered the roads and fields." The words the author choose for this line described both the appearance of the character, the setting, and also gives a glimpse of whats happening. When he says that corpses littered the field it gave me the impression that the country was in crisis. This description also impacted my mood. I felt sympathy for the character who is described as a skeletal apparition because they must not have food to eat, and sadness for the dead bodies, because they all still had much more to live for especially the young ones and for the families that are now incomplete. I can't imagine how it would feel to lose a parent or a sibling.
I believe that the author conveyed evil and darkness mostly through the characters. Evil is displayed through the Hutu's. These men killed countless number of people at a church. "The killers moved into the terrified crowd of men, women and children, hacking and clubbing as they went." They showed no mercy to whom they were killing, and they did it with torture. "There were children begging for pity but they killed them straight away." Many of these men were knew who they were killing. They were killing their neighbours. "Valentina recognised many of her Hutu neighbours among the more than 30 men" They were told to kill everyone and spare no lives and so they did it exactly. "We couldn't spare the children's lives. Our orders were to kill everyone." The person who posessed the power to tell these men to kill others was the start of evil. He uses his power for evil thus making others evil. The Hutus didnt even spare the lives of infants. They did exactly what they were told no matter how inhumane it was and this represents great evil and darkness.
What impacted me the most was the story of Valentina, and the story she tells of her past. It inspires me how after all that she had been through at such a young age, she still has hope.
The article was about a man who had taken part in the killings of the church where Valentina was. He explains how he killed his friends, neighbours and spared no lives. He said that the killers were fighting over the victims. This shows great darkness in the hearts of these men. They were bloodthirsty for lives of the tutsi's, even for the children. Evil has no limits, there are no exceptions. They couldve at least spared the lives of children but didn't
The author conveys and integrate imagery, setting and work on mood through his descriptions and the details associated with it. "...skeletal apparition lying on a camp bed in a country where corpses littered the roads and fields." The words the author choose for this line described both the appearance of the character, the setting, and also gives a glimpse of whats happening. When he says that corpses littered the field it gave me the impression that the country was in crisis. This description also impacted my mood. I felt sympathy for the character who is described as a skeletal apparition because they must not have food to eat, and sadness for the dead bodies, because they all still had much more to live for especially the young ones and for the families that are now incomplete. I can't imagine how it would feel to lose a parent or a sibling.
I believe that the author conveyed evil and darkness mostly through the characters. Evil is displayed through the Hutu's. These men killed countless number of people at a church. "The killers moved into the terrified crowd of men, women and children, hacking and clubbing as they went." They showed no mercy to whom they were killing, and they did it with torture. "There were children begging for pity but they killed them straight away." Many of these men were knew who they were killing. They were killing their neighbours. "Valentina recognised many of her Hutu neighbours among the more than 30 men" They were told to kill everyone and spare no lives and so they did it exactly. "We couldn't spare the children's lives. Our orders were to kill everyone." The person who posessed the power to tell these men to kill others was the start of evil. He uses his power for evil thus making others evil. The Hutus didnt even spare the lives of infants. They did exactly what they were told no matter how inhumane it was and this represents great evil and darkness.
What impacted me the most was the story of Valentina, and the story she tells of her past. It inspires me how after all that she had been through at such a young age, she still has hope.
Monday, January 18, 2010
Sunday, January 17, 2010
Response to short story: The Destructors
Violence is the result of evil and darkness. It is an inevitable aspect of a society and exists when people do not agree with one another, or when people fighting over something, such as land. I believe that there are good people because of evil.
The short story, "The Destructor" was an interesting read about a boys gang, called the Wormsley Common Gang. Everyday they meet at an old parking lot and plan a new way to spend their day, usually up to to something mischievous. They follow the ideas of their gang leader, Blackie. When Trevor, "T" is recruited into the gang, he devises a plan to destroy a 200 year old house. Under T their new leader, they execute their plan when the owner of the house, "Old Misery", goes on vacation. Their plan is to cause destruction to the inside of the house as much as possible. In the end, all that's left of the house was dusty rubble.
What impacted me most about this story is how the gang's meaning of fun, or just something to do is to cause destruction or break the law. I wonder how they benefited from destroying Old Misery's home. There was no valid reason for doing so, Old Misery had done nothing wrong to them except give them 3 packages of chocolate. Even after a kind act, they retaliate by leaving him without a home. This impacted me because it really made me think of other reasons why evil exists. I wonder if it exists for the mere enjoyment or pleasure of some people. I feel that evil and darkness in this short story was conveyed through the characters. Blackie and T were the two characters who i felt displayed the most power and evil that came along with their ideas.
"T, whose words were almost confined to voting ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ to the plan of operations proposed each day by Blackie..." This quote shows that Blackie possesses power. He decides on the daily plans and these plans are destructive and dark.
"T was giving his orders with decision..." As the story progressed, T gained leadership and devised new evil plans.
The short story, "The Destructor" was an interesting read about a boys gang, called the Wormsley Common Gang. Everyday they meet at an old parking lot and plan a new way to spend their day, usually up to to something mischievous. They follow the ideas of their gang leader, Blackie. When Trevor, "T" is recruited into the gang, he devises a plan to destroy a 200 year old house. Under T their new leader, they execute their plan when the owner of the house, "Old Misery", goes on vacation. Their plan is to cause destruction to the inside of the house as much as possible. In the end, all that's left of the house was dusty rubble.
What impacted me most about this story is how the gang's meaning of fun, or just something to do is to cause destruction or break the law. I wonder how they benefited from destroying Old Misery's home. There was no valid reason for doing so, Old Misery had done nothing wrong to them except give them 3 packages of chocolate. Even after a kind act, they retaliate by leaving him without a home. This impacted me because it really made me think of other reasons why evil exists. I wonder if it exists for the mere enjoyment or pleasure of some people. I feel that evil and darkness in this short story was conveyed through the characters. Blackie and T were the two characters who i felt displayed the most power and evil that came along with their ideas.
"T, whose words were almost confined to voting ‘Yes’ or ‘No’ to the plan of operations proposed each day by Blackie..." This quote shows that Blackie possesses power. He decides on the daily plans and these plans are destructive and dark.
"T was giving his orders with decision..." As the story progressed, T gained leadership and devised new evil plans.
Sunday, December 6, 2009
Response
You have great insight into the nurture aspect of human life. You have many points to support your answer. I would like you to back up your points with a specific quote from the text. This will further support what you are saying. Overall well said and you definitely have a solid understanding of the story and M.
Tuesday, December 1, 2009
EQ ANALYSIS
Essential question: Does nature or nurture determine one's destiny?
Destiny is a predetermined, usually inevitable, course of events. No one has complete control of their destiny; it is something that nature controls. Although, I believe that one can direct them self to a desired destiny, through decisions, but not necessarily control it. With every choice that is made, the "direction" to their destiny shifts accordingly. For example, bad decisions can shift them to the direction of an undesirable destiny and vice versa. Nevertheless, sometimes decisions don't affect one's destiny at all, but for Macbeth, it was a matter of life and death.
I believe that nature should determine one's destiny. Destiny is something that cannot and should not be manipulated. I feel that if nurture was to determine one's destiny, it would lead to the exact opposite of what was desired. Connecting my essential question to Macbeth; the three witches had predicted Macbeth's future and destiny. They influenced his thinking and made him believe that he could have all the power his heart desired, with just a mere task of eliminating the current King. Macbeth would have never even considered killing the king, the man he was most loyal to, until the witches foretold what was going to happen. The witches were the ones who started Macbeth’s blood-thirsty quest for power. If the witches hadn't told him that he would be king, he would've never gotten the desire for power, and power would have never corrupted him, a once noble hero. Lady Macbeth was also overcome with the desire and greed for power, that she continued to persuade him and ensured that the witches' prediction would come true. She encouraged Macbeth to follow through with his decisions and actions and made sure he didn’t change his mind. Considering this, even if Macbeth changed his mind, Lady Macbeth would not have let him. It was not only Macbeth that controlled his destiny, he was influenced by the ones around him and so it was not nature that intended for him to become king. His fate as king was created by the witches, Lady Macbeth, murder and lies. Since nature did not determine Macbeth's destiny, it was never meant to be, and so the result was not what Macbeth expected. What I perceive from the story of Macbeth is that you cannot cheat or escape your destiny. Macbeth wasn’t destined to be king and so destiny found a way to take the crown away from him and gave him what he deserved. Macbeth was influenced by a lot of people, and this also contributed to the fact that his destiny was a lie. True destiny is by one's own decisions and actions, not by others.
I agree that if Macbeth became king by nature and his own decisions and actions, he would have been a great leader. He knew how to be leader, but he took advantage of that, which led to the deaths of many people including him self. He abused his power and used it to use people. It was like he created his own world, his own reality and everything revolved around him. This is one way of how power can corrupt. People with power are somewhat blinded from what’s really out there and perceive others as merely orbiting around them. Despite the fact the fact that it was also Macbeth’s decisions to believe the witches and listen to Lady Macbeth, I feel that he was a victim in a way. He was being influenced by the witches and was manipulated by his wife. They all contributed to his downfall. In my opinion, after analyzing the reasons for Macbeth’s failure, I have come to a conclusion that Macbeth is a tragic hero. Although he was manipulated and influenced, it was still his choice to be manipulated, and to be influenced. He still has control over himself and he should’ve known what was right from wrong and not listened to the witches and Lady Macbeth.
Destiny is a predetermined, usually inevitable, course of events. No one has complete control of their destiny; it is something that nature controls. Although, I believe that one can direct them self to a desired destiny, through decisions, but not necessarily control it. With every choice that is made, the "direction" to their destiny shifts accordingly. For example, bad decisions can shift them to the direction of an undesirable destiny and vice versa. Nevertheless, sometimes decisions don't affect one's destiny at all, but for Macbeth, it was a matter of life and death.
I believe that nature should determine one's destiny. Destiny is something that cannot and should not be manipulated. I feel that if nurture was to determine one's destiny, it would lead to the exact opposite of what was desired. Connecting my essential question to Macbeth; the three witches had predicted Macbeth's future and destiny. They influenced his thinking and made him believe that he could have all the power his heart desired, with just a mere task of eliminating the current King. Macbeth would have never even considered killing the king, the man he was most loyal to, until the witches foretold what was going to happen. The witches were the ones who started Macbeth’s blood-thirsty quest for power. If the witches hadn't told him that he would be king, he would've never gotten the desire for power, and power would have never corrupted him, a once noble hero. Lady Macbeth was also overcome with the desire and greed for power, that she continued to persuade him and ensured that the witches' prediction would come true. She encouraged Macbeth to follow through with his decisions and actions and made sure he didn’t change his mind. Considering this, even if Macbeth changed his mind, Lady Macbeth would not have let him. It was not only Macbeth that controlled his destiny, he was influenced by the ones around him and so it was not nature that intended for him to become king. His fate as king was created by the witches, Lady Macbeth, murder and lies. Since nature did not determine Macbeth's destiny, it was never meant to be, and so the result was not what Macbeth expected. What I perceive from the story of Macbeth is that you cannot cheat or escape your destiny. Macbeth wasn’t destined to be king and so destiny found a way to take the crown away from him and gave him what he deserved. Macbeth was influenced by a lot of people, and this also contributed to the fact that his destiny was a lie. True destiny is by one's own decisions and actions, not by others.
I agree that if Macbeth became king by nature and his own decisions and actions, he would have been a great leader. He knew how to be leader, but he took advantage of that, which led to the deaths of many people including him self. He abused his power and used it to use people. It was like he created his own world, his own reality and everything revolved around him. This is one way of how power can corrupt. People with power are somewhat blinded from what’s really out there and perceive others as merely orbiting around them. Despite the fact the fact that it was also Macbeth’s decisions to believe the witches and listen to Lady Macbeth, I feel that he was a victim in a way. He was being influenced by the witches and was manipulated by his wife. They all contributed to his downfall. In my opinion, after analyzing the reasons for Macbeth’s failure, I have come to a conclusion that Macbeth is a tragic hero. Although he was manipulated and influenced, it was still his choice to be manipulated, and to be influenced. He still has control over himself and he should’ve known what was right from wrong and not listened to the witches and Lady Macbeth.
Saturday, November 28, 2009
Reflection / Tragic hero? Nov 27, 2009
My group decided to choose the method of presenting our knowledge through a video. We felt that it would be much easier to present our knowledge this way because we would be portraying the characters in Macbeth showing that we are knowledgeable of what is happening. We attempted to emphasize the important aspects which also shows that we understand the content and we are able to visualize it. Such as Lady Macbeth's sleep walking scene, and Macbeth's fight. Other reasons that contributed to the decision of making a movie is the fact that it is an enjoyable and interesting way to present our understanding. I found it involves a lot more creative thinking and more work, but it caught our audiences attention which is another key aspect to a good presentation.
Our influences for this presentation were YouTube clips that related to Macbeth, such as the Macbeth Rap. It gave us the idea of rapping in scenes of our movie to interest the audience. Music is a big part of our society, and I feel by incorporating music with our learning, it really makes it all worth while.
I felt that this presentation was a lot different than past presentations because we were given the chance to choose how we would like present this to the class. I found that really neat because we are usually asked to present in a specific way and so everyone's presentation will be similar. The sky was the limit for our presentations and I found it much easier to pick a way to present because our choices weren't limited and we can let our creativity go beyond its limits. Also, each group had different ideas and were all presented differently, meaning I didn't have to watch the same presentation ten times. I love variety and uniqueness.
This presentation was challenging at some parts, but much easier in other parts. Making a video and editing it was no easy task. I felt that it took much more time and effort but it was worth it because it was enjoyable. It was challenging because of all the effort we put into it. Although, we found that it was easier, compared to past presentations, to present our understanding visually, rather than explaining it through words.
I have found that ever since we started blogging I write more on my private blog that the class blog. I think it's because sometimes I feel more comfortable expressing my ideas and opinions when only a limited number of people can see it. Although sometimes I feel that my peers should see what i have to say, but not all the time. Also, I find it much easier to access my own blog because I am more familiar with it than the class blog.
I learned from the class presentations that a tragic hero is a hero who suffers a tragic flaw, and then faces a tragedy which leads to their downfall. I feel that Macbeth is between being a tragic hero and not being a tragic hero. My opinion lies in between because although it was Macbeth's actions that led to his own downfall, it wasn't entirely his decisions. He was influenced by the witches who gave him the idea that he can be king by killing the king. Macbeth would have never thought of committing such a crime if it wasn't for the witches and he would have remained a noble hero. He was also manipulated by his wife Lady Macbeth who was greedy for power and she too convinced Macbeth to kill the king. I feel that Macbeth didn't make himself a tragic hero, but the people around him did, and this is what led him to his death. Overall, I think that he did not make his own decisions which means that he is in between the lines of a tragic hero.
Quotes that show Macbeth was a tragic hero:
First a tragic hero must be a hero:
"O valiant cousin! Worthy gentleman!" Here King Duncan is praising Macbeth for his bravery and calling him a worthy man, showing that he is a noble hero.
Then they must face a tragedy or have a flaw:
"Is this a dagger which I see before me..." Here Macbeth is having thoughts of killing the king and contemplating whether to do it or not. He begins to hallucinate and sees a bloody dagger floating in the air and this is what he will use to kill King Duncan.
Then their downfall:
"Behold where stands. The usurper’s cursèd head. The time is free." Macduff is carrying Macbeth's head and stating that they are now free from his tyranny.
The essential questions; how does power corrupt and how far is one willing to go to get what they desire the most shows that Macbeth would do anything to get power such as kill the King and was corrupted with the desire and hunger for power before and after he got power. This is part of what made him a tragic hero and this is what led to his downfall. But as I said before, it was not entirely his choices that led to his failure.
Celeste H.
Our influences for this presentation were YouTube clips that related to Macbeth, such as the Macbeth Rap. It gave us the idea of rapping in scenes of our movie to interest the audience. Music is a big part of our society, and I feel by incorporating music with our learning, it really makes it all worth while.
I felt that this presentation was a lot different than past presentations because we were given the chance to choose how we would like present this to the class. I found that really neat because we are usually asked to present in a specific way and so everyone's presentation will be similar. The sky was the limit for our presentations and I found it much easier to pick a way to present because our choices weren't limited and we can let our creativity go beyond its limits. Also, each group had different ideas and were all presented differently, meaning I didn't have to watch the same presentation ten times. I love variety and uniqueness.
This presentation was challenging at some parts, but much easier in other parts. Making a video and editing it was no easy task. I felt that it took much more time and effort but it was worth it because it was enjoyable. It was challenging because of all the effort we put into it. Although, we found that it was easier, compared to past presentations, to present our understanding visually, rather than explaining it through words.
I have found that ever since we started blogging I write more on my private blog that the class blog. I think it's because sometimes I feel more comfortable expressing my ideas and opinions when only a limited number of people can see it. Although sometimes I feel that my peers should see what i have to say, but not all the time. Also, I find it much easier to access my own blog because I am more familiar with it than the class blog.
I learned from the class presentations that a tragic hero is a hero who suffers a tragic flaw, and then faces a tragedy which leads to their downfall. I feel that Macbeth is between being a tragic hero and not being a tragic hero. My opinion lies in between because although it was Macbeth's actions that led to his own downfall, it wasn't entirely his decisions. He was influenced by the witches who gave him the idea that he can be king by killing the king. Macbeth would have never thought of committing such a crime if it wasn't for the witches and he would have remained a noble hero. He was also manipulated by his wife Lady Macbeth who was greedy for power and she too convinced Macbeth to kill the king. I feel that Macbeth didn't make himself a tragic hero, but the people around him did, and this is what led him to his death. Overall, I think that he did not make his own decisions which means that he is in between the lines of a tragic hero.
Quotes that show Macbeth was a tragic hero:
First a tragic hero must be a hero:
"O valiant cousin! Worthy gentleman!" Here King Duncan is praising Macbeth for his bravery and calling him a worthy man, showing that he is a noble hero.
Then they must face a tragedy or have a flaw:
"Is this a dagger which I see before me..." Here Macbeth is having thoughts of killing the king and contemplating whether to do it or not. He begins to hallucinate and sees a bloody dagger floating in the air and this is what he will use to kill King Duncan.
Then their downfall:
"Behold where stands. The usurper’s cursèd head. The time is free." Macduff is carrying Macbeth's head and stating that they are now free from his tyranny.
The essential questions; how does power corrupt and how far is one willing to go to get what they desire the most shows that Macbeth would do anything to get power such as kill the King and was corrupted with the desire and hunger for power before and after he got power. This is part of what made him a tragic hero and this is what led to his downfall. But as I said before, it was not entirely his choices that led to his failure.
Celeste H.
Thursday, November 26, 2009
What I am going to remember about the presentations.
I truly enjoyed the Macbeth unit and the different approaches we took to further develop our understandings of the important aspects of the play. It surprised me how every single group in the class each presented their act in different ways. There were speeches, videos, slide shows and it helped me understand even more because it was all visual learning. I hope to have more opportunities and projects like this to present my understanding of a unit.
There are many things I am going to remember about the Macbeth presentations. Firstly the creativity and originality of the presentations, as well as the humor. I am also going to remember all the key scenes of each act because of how they were emphasized and presented. I find it much easier to remember an act acted out by my classmates, or an act that i acted out myself. It makes it much easier to imagine the act after seeing my classmates play it out. It's much easier to remember an act that was incorporated with humor as well. I never forget something that makes me laugh. I am also going to remember the act which was presented as a cartoon. It was very amusing and it told the story well. It was impressive how the animation and sound was put together. We get better and better at technology each and everyday and this is a great part of our learning. Last but not least, I will remember the essential questions that connected to Macbeth and how each group explained how their EQ connected with their act. I find that I get a wider range of thinking which deepens my understanding if I hear another person's or group's opinion on something. I start to think outside the box and it helps me develop further thinking which I find very helpful.
There are many things I am going to remember about the Macbeth presentations. Firstly the creativity and originality of the presentations, as well as the humor. I am also going to remember all the key scenes of each act because of how they were emphasized and presented. I find it much easier to remember an act acted out by my classmates, or an act that i acted out myself. It makes it much easier to imagine the act after seeing my classmates play it out. It's much easier to remember an act that was incorporated with humor as well. I never forget something that makes me laugh. I am also going to remember the act which was presented as a cartoon. It was very amusing and it told the story well. It was impressive how the animation and sound was put together. We get better and better at technology each and everyday and this is a great part of our learning. Last but not least, I will remember the essential questions that connected to Macbeth and how each group explained how their EQ connected with their act. I find that I get a wider range of thinking which deepens my understanding if I hear another person's or group's opinion on something. I start to think outside the box and it helps me develop further thinking which I find very helpful.
Sunday, November 22, 2009
Learning Log #3
After portraying the characters in Macbeth for our student film, i was able to answer another essential question: How does technology change/impact the way we communicate and learn?
After spending the whole block filming our movie, I noticed that making a movie was another fun and great way to present your understanding of a unit, because you are actually putting yourself in your character's shoe and acting like him/her. For example, acting like Macbeth, you had to be demanding, intimidating and speak with a confident and firm tone. This shows that Macbeth has power and strength. So by using technology such as a camera and the computer for editing, we are able to make our very own film and incorporate our creativity in it, such as humor and music. This will interest our viewers which is a key part in any presentation.
After spending the whole block filming our movie, I noticed that making a movie was another fun and great way to present your understanding of a unit, because you are actually putting yourself in your character's shoe and acting like him/her. For example, acting like Macbeth, you had to be demanding, intimidating and speak with a confident and firm tone. This shows that Macbeth has power and strength. So by using technology such as a camera and the computer for editing, we are able to make our very own film and incorporate our creativity in it, such as humor and music. This will interest our viewers which is a key part in any presentation.
Friday, November 13, 2009
Daily Learnings on Macbeth # 2
What I learned today was making a video takes a lot of time effort and Macbeth is a great story to work around. It has all the key elements of a movie which i discovered is very helpful in this project. By incorporating comedy, action and drama into this i feel that it will be a successful video that im sure everyone will enjoy watching.
Working in a group is very helpful for me. It's more fun and we have alot more ideas because there are more people to share their opinions. Also, the work is less for each individual which is also very helpful. Its an opportunity to build team skills.
Working in a group is very helpful for me. It's more fun and we have alot more ideas because there are more people to share their opinions. Also, the work is less for each individual which is also very helpful. Its an opportunity to build team skills.
Saturday, November 7, 2009
Daily Learnings on Macbeth
After finishing the story of Macbeth, I learned that what goes around comes around. Macbeth was corrupted by power, he killed men, woman and children. He had taken the lives of the innocent in the attempt of remaining king. Throughout the movie, he acted from selfish motives and he didn't care about anyone else. He did whatever it takes to ensure his place as king. By doing this, it cost him his life. His actions bounced right back to him, and he died for taking the lives of others.
I believe that good things will come to you if you do good for others. But Macbeth no longer had control of his conscience and was a changed man. In my opinion Macbeth deserved to die although the witches influenced him, the witches only told him the future that he could build but, he built it.Power truly has the ability to change lives as well as ruin them.
I believe that good things will come to you if you do good for others. But Macbeth no longer had control of his conscience and was a changed man. In my opinion Macbeth deserved to die although the witches influenced him, the witches only told him the future that he could build but, he built it.Power truly has the ability to change lives as well as ruin them.
Friday, November 6, 2009
Group Work ACT V
The people in my group are Sean, Mitch and Ryan. We decided to create a video relating to the important aspects of Macbeth Act 5. We will all be playing equal roles, but we haven't decided the specific roles yet. I will be in charge of the editing of the video and we will be using my camera and stand to film the scenes. We will create a story related to Macbeth and we will be addressing the essential questions, such as: how does power corrupt, and what determines one's destiny etc. We will also try to incorporate some comedy to keep the audience interested.
What I know so far about Act 5 of macbeth, is that many people start to go against him because they realized he was a selfish king corrupted by power. Macduff wants revenge for the death of his family and so joins Malcolm, the rightful king, to attack Macbeth and remove his as king. The witches had told macbeth that no man conceived my a woman can defeat him. As he fights with Macduff, he finds out that macduff was not conceived through vaginal birth and so macbeth was defeated. Malcolm takes his place as rightful king.
What I know so far about Act 5 of macbeth, is that many people start to go against him because they realized he was a selfish king corrupted by power. Macduff wants revenge for the death of his family and so joins Malcolm, the rightful king, to attack Macbeth and remove his as king. The witches had told macbeth that no man conceived my a woman can defeat him. As he fights with Macduff, he finds out that macduff was not conceived through vaginal birth and so macbeth was defeated. Malcolm takes his place as rightful king.
Thursday, November 5, 2009
Monday, November 2, 2009
Essential Question
Does nature or nurture determine one's destiny?
I believe that nature should determine one's destiny. In Macbeth, the witches had predicted Macbeth's future and destiny, it was not only Macbeth that controlled it. His destiny as king was created by murder. It is a lie, and it did not happen by nature. Lady Macbeth had also helped create his destiny because of her desire and greed. In this story, nature did not determined Macbeth's destiny, meaning it was never meant to be. If the witches hadn't told him that he would be king, he would've never gotten the determination for power. Macbeth was influenced by a lot of people, and this also makes his destiny a lie. True destiny is by one's own decisions and actions, not by others.
I believe that nature should determine one's destiny. In Macbeth, the witches had predicted Macbeth's future and destiny, it was not only Macbeth that controlled it. His destiny as king was created by murder. It is a lie, and it did not happen by nature. Lady Macbeth had also helped create his destiny because of her desire and greed. In this story, nature did not determined Macbeth's destiny, meaning it was never meant to be. If the witches hadn't told him that he would be king, he would've never gotten the determination for power. Macbeth was influenced by a lot of people, and this also makes his destiny a lie. True destiny is by one's own decisions and actions, not by others.
Wednesday, October 28, 2009
POSTCARD

Dear Bob...
I am currently studying one of Shakespeare's wonderful plays, Macbeth. I am understanding that Macbeth was a man of unsure decisions and greed. He wanted power and he would do anything to get that, even kill. His choices were also influenced by Lady Macbeth after she persuaded him to kill the King. The King's death was not only Macbeth's fault but also the Lady's. She too desired power and she could get that through her husband. Lady Macbeth was willing to sacrifice her husbands honor and life by making him kill The King. So far i have learned that desire is a powerful thing, sometimes people cannot control it, even if it means resorting to inhumane actions. Having power can corrupt a person, but so can desiring it.
I'm hoping to learn more about the deeper meaning to this story. I'll be updating telling you a lot more about my English 11 experience.
Peace out,
Celeste H.
Tuesday, October 27, 2009
Act 1 Macbeth Debrief
Two truths told are told,
As happy prologues to the swelling act
Of the imperial theme. - I thank you, gentleman.-
[Aside] This supernatural soliciting
Cannot be ill; cannot be good: if ill,
Why hath it given me earnest of success,
Commencing in a truth? I am thane of Cawdor:
if good, why do I yield to that suggestion
Whose horrid image doth unfix my hair
In this passage, one of the visions told by the witches had come true, Macbeth had taken the thane of Cawdor. Since one of the visions became true, Macbeth is now wondering if the next vision, of him becoming king, will come true. He starts to have mental images of himself killing the king, the person he is loyal and devoted to. Something that he would've never imagined himself doing, if he hadn't been told that he was to become king. His desire grows strongly, his desire to have power and become king, and he would do anything to achieve it.
Macbeth was the king's loyal general and he would die for him. King Duncan also had a lot of trust in Macbeth, he trusted him with his life. Although, the desire for power had corrupted Macbeth to the limit where he would kill for what he wanted, he was willing to throw away the trust and friendship he shared with the King.
This passage shows that loyalty can be broken because of the desire for power. Macbeth's loyalty to his king slowly decreased because he wanted what his king had, POWER.
Celeste H.
As happy prologues to the swelling act
Of the imperial theme. - I thank you, gentleman.-
[Aside] This supernatural soliciting
Cannot be ill; cannot be good: if ill,
Why hath it given me earnest of success,
Commencing in a truth? I am thane of Cawdor:
if good, why do I yield to that suggestion
Whose horrid image doth unfix my hair
In this passage, one of the visions told by the witches had come true, Macbeth had taken the thane of Cawdor. Since one of the visions became true, Macbeth is now wondering if the next vision, of him becoming king, will come true. He starts to have mental images of himself killing the king, the person he is loyal and devoted to. Something that he would've never imagined himself doing, if he hadn't been told that he was to become king. His desire grows strongly, his desire to have power and become king, and he would do anything to achieve it.
Macbeth was the king's loyal general and he would die for him. King Duncan also had a lot of trust in Macbeth, he trusted him with his life. Although, the desire for power had corrupted Macbeth to the limit where he would kill for what he wanted, he was willing to throw away the trust and friendship he shared with the King.
This passage shows that loyalty can be broken because of the desire for power. Macbeth's loyalty to his king slowly decreased because he wanted what his king had, POWER.
Celeste H.
Wednesday, October 21, 2009
Response
Way to go! You figured out how to do Wordle on your own! Thanks to your friends for showing you how to do it. I still haven't quite mastered how to get it from my pc into my blog. One day.
On another note, when you watch Macbeth you find it easier to understand, what other influences are present that enable you understand it better? For example you said you could actually see the battle scene, but what other influences exist when we see a movie version of a book?
On another note, when you watch Macbeth you find it easier to understand, what other influences are present that enable you understand it better? For example you said you could actually see the battle scene, but what other influences exist when we see a movie version of a book?
Tuesday, October 20, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

