WELCOME!

Tuesday, December 1, 2009

EQ ANALYSIS

Essential question: Does nature or nurture determine one's destiny?

Destiny is a predetermined, usually inevitable, course of events. No one has complete control of their destiny; it is something that nature controls. Although, I believe that one can direct them self to a desired destiny, through decisions, but not necessarily control it. With every choice that is made, the "direction" to their destiny shifts accordingly. For example, bad decisions can shift them to the direction of an undesirable destiny and vice versa. Nevertheless, sometimes decisions don't affect one's destiny at all, but for Macbeth, it was a matter of life and death.

I believe that nature should determine one's destiny. Destiny is something that cannot and should not be manipulated. I feel that if nurture was to determine one's destiny, it would lead to the exact opposite of what was desired. Connecting my essential question to Macbeth; the three witches had predicted Macbeth's future and destiny. They influenced his thinking and made him believe that he could have all the power his heart desired, with just a mere task of eliminating the current King. Macbeth would have never even considered killing the king, the man he was most loyal to, until the witches foretold what was going to happen. The witches were the ones who started Macbeth’s blood-thirsty quest for power. If the witches hadn't told him that he would be king, he would've never gotten the desire for power, and power would have never corrupted him, a once noble hero. Lady Macbeth was also overcome with the desire and greed for power, that she continued to persuade him and ensured that the witches' prediction would come true. She encouraged Macbeth to follow through with his decisions and actions and made sure he didn’t change his mind. Considering this, even if Macbeth changed his mind, Lady Macbeth would not have let him. It was not only Macbeth that controlled his destiny, he was influenced by the ones around him and so it was not nature that intended for him to become king. His fate as king was created by the witches, Lady Macbeth, murder and lies. Since nature did not determine Macbeth's destiny, it was never meant to be, and so the result was not what Macbeth expected. What I perceive from the story of Macbeth is that you cannot cheat or escape your destiny. Macbeth wasn’t destined to be king and so destiny found a way to take the crown away from him and gave him what he deserved. Macbeth was influenced by a lot of people, and this also contributed to the fact that his destiny was a lie. True destiny is by one's own decisions and actions, not by others.

I agree that if Macbeth became king by nature and his own decisions and actions, he would have been a great leader. He knew how to be leader, but he took advantage of that, which led to the deaths of many people including him self. He abused his power and used it to use people. It was like he created his own world, his own reality and everything revolved around him. This is one way of how power can corrupt. People with power are somewhat blinded from what’s really out there and perceive others as merely orbiting around them. Despite the fact the fact that it was also Macbeth’s decisions to believe the witches and listen to Lady Macbeth, I feel that he was a victim in a way. He was being influenced by the witches and was manipulated by his wife. They all contributed to his downfall. In my opinion, after analyzing the reasons for Macbeth’s failure, I have come to a conclusion that Macbeth is a tragic hero. Although he was manipulated and influenced, it was still his choice to be manipulated, and to be influenced. He still has control over himself and he should’ve known what was right from wrong and not listened to the witches and Lady Macbeth.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Powered By Blogger